|
I brought "The Thirteenth Tale" on vacation with me and I was finished before I left. Diane Setterfield's got this ghost story/mystery packed full of curiosities that will have you searching for the answers until the end.
There were too many elements that didn't fit together, too many questions left unanswered. A lot of loose ends were left, but not in the purposeful way a skillful writer might leave his or her readers thinking after the book ends.
I had high hopes for this book, so I was disappointed when I wasn't immediately engaged. As I read on, I found that I did want to keep reading.
I am an avid reader and usually get really wrapped up in the books I read. So much of the ending of this book just didn't make sense.
I kept waiting for some kind of major plot twist or revelation. I guess you can say the plot twist came, but it was very disappointed.
Instead, I felt like these plot holes were a result of the fact that much of what Setterfield tried to do with this book just didn't work. So although I found some of the characters intriguing, and although I thought the book showed a lot of promise and potential, I was ultimately disappointed.
If it wasn't a book club pick I would have dumped it about page 100. I just don't get it. this was one of the most painful books I have ever read. Very tedious read - so tired of overrated reviews and fiction with a total lack of substance. Big waste of time.
I have a new favorite book. I want to read it again and again and again1.
My emotions were were twisted and twisted as I read this novel. The secrets, the ghosts, the books, and the people transported me to various places and times. From page 1 right to the end, Diane Setterfield enraptured my mind with a story about a story intertwined with several stories. Towards the end I THOUGHT I had it figured out only to realize I completely missed things earlier in the stories. I was filled with an anxiety, a need, to solve the puzzle of The Thirteenth Tale by Vida Winters as the clues were laid before Margaret Lea and me, the reader. How can you really talk about this book other than it was a great book that I have to have for my bookshelf and one that I know I'll want to read again another time and perhaps another. THAT'S a good book. One that throws me off, one that grabs and twists my emotions, and one that touches my soul as a sister.FIVE STARS.
|